LinuxLinks has kindly given me space for a semi-regular blog about open source, Linux, Windows and whatever else catches my attention. The views and prejudices are my own.
Somewhere, somebody is wiping a perfectly good Linux installation because a bloke on YouTube has convinced them that another distribution will revolutionise their workflow. Their current system works. The applications launch, the printer prints and nothing has crashed in months. But the grass is apparently greener on the other side of the package manager. By Sunday evening, they’ve reinstalled Firefox, LibreOffice and their favourite music player, restored their files and spent several hours fixing things that worked perfectly well on Friday. An entire weekend devoted to getting back to where they started.
Welcome to distro hopping, the Linux community’s favourite way of confusing activity with accomplishment. I’ve nothing against experimenting with computers, but I do question the idea that repeatedly replacing a working operating system represents progress. For someone who spends most of their day in a browser, office suite and music player, switching distributions often changes remarkably little beyond the wallpaper and the location of a few settings.
The productivity illusion
I keep reading claims that switching distributions has transformed someone’s productivity. Does LibreOffice suddenly produce better documents under Fedora? Does Firefox render websites more intelligently on Arch? Does replacing GNOME with KDE Plasma make your emails worth reading? Of course, different desktop environments offer genuinely useful features, but the breathless claims of productivity breakthroughs often amount to little more than enthusiasm for something new. Perhaps the greatest productivity improvement would be to stop reinstalling Linux and actually get some work done.
What exactly was broken?
There are perfectly sensible reasons to switch distributions. Better hardware support, troublesome updates, an inconvenient release cycle or a desktop that no longer meets your needs are all legitimate complaints. But “it feels cleaner” isn’t much of a technical argument, and neither is saving 300MB of RAM at idle. Congratulations, you’ve freed enough memory to open a few more browser tabs, presumably to watch videos about your next distribution.
I’m particularly amused by people who painstakingly recreate their old setup on a new distribution. Same applications, same browser profile, same keyboard shortcuts and often the same desktop layout. After several hours resolving unexpected differences, everything finally behaves exactly as it did before. Which rather raises the question of why they bothered changing in the first place.
Tinkering doesn’t need an excuse
Before anyone reaches for their keyboard, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with distro hopping as a hobby. Linux encourages experimentation, and trying an unfamiliar distribution or window manager can be enjoyable and educational. I’ve wasted countless hours investigating software simply because I was curious. People spend their weekends restoring old cars or rebuilding bicycles that already work. Nobody demands proof that the exercise has improved their productivity.
The problem starts when enthusiasts present their hobby as essential advice for everyone else. Not everybody wants their computer to be an ongoing project. Someone who needs a reliable desktop to earn a living may have little interest in spending Sunday afternoon discovering why their scanner no longer works. Some people just want to use the bloody thing.
Perhaps you’ve already found the best distribution
There’s a peculiar obsession within parts of the Linux community with finding the perfect distribution. Keep searching, keep installing and eventually you’ll discover computing nirvana. Except that yesterday’s revolutionary distribution invariably becomes tomorrow’s boring old installation, and the search begins again. There’s no medal for running the newest kernel, no certificate for having the tidiest desktop and no particular glory in boasting that your system uses less memory than a digital alarm clock.
If your distribution causes problems, replace it. If you’re curious about another, try it in a virtual machine or on a spare drive. But if everything works, perhaps leave it alone and do something useful instead. Your operating system doesn’t have to be exciting. It has to work.
And if you really must spend another weekend reinstalling Linux, at least admit you’re doing it for fun rather than pretending you’ve discovered the secret to productivity.
Did your last distro switch actually solve a problem, or were you simply bored?
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.